See quot. 1805.

1

1784.  The fish common to the waters of the Ohio are the buffalo fish, of a large size, and the cat-fish, sometimes exceeding one hundred weight.—John Filson, ‘Kentucke,’ p. 26.

2

1792.  The buffalo fish is in size from 4 to 8 lb. is a very fine fish.—G. Imlay, ‘Topographical Description [Ky.],’ p. 154.

3

1805.  Buffalo-Fish, so called by the Indians and Europeans, on account of its being heard sometimes to bellow in the water.—Thaddeus M. Harris, ‘State of Ohio,’ p. 116. (Italics in the original.)

4

1861.  These rivers are very fine for buffalo fish to live in.—W. H. Russell in The Times, July 10. (N.E.D.)

5