vbl. sb. [f. as prec. + -ING1.] The action of the verb WITHHOLD: retention, restraint, keeping back, etc.

1

c. 1386.  Chaucer, Melib., ¶ 267. How I shal gouerne me in the chesynge and in the withholdynge of my conseillours.

2

c. 1400.  trans. Secreta Secret., Gov. Lordsh., 116. Broodnesse of brest, and greetnesse of sholdres … by-tokyns … hardynesse, with witholdynge of wyt, and vndyrstondynge.

3

c. 1430.  Pilgr. Lyf Manhode, II. lii. (1869), 96. So is to me an hevy blok the bodi, and a gret withholdinge.

4

1440–1.  Privy Counc. Proc. (P.R.O.). Thendentures of his withholdyng bitwix the Kyng and him.

5

c. 1450.  Godstow Reg., 351. That they shulde receyue the tythys … with-out ony with-holdynge.

6

1454.  Rolls of Parlt., V. 254/1. That a notable some of monneye bee to me delivered … for the witholding and contenting of such Souldeours.

7

1526.  Reg. Privy Seal Scot., I. 518/2. Thair tressonable assegeing, taking and withhalding of the Kingis castell.

8

a. 1651.  C. Love, Combat Flesh & Spirit (1654), 41. The withholdings of the Spirit.

9

1705.  Stanhope, Paraphr., II. 350. His very Withholdings and Delays are kindly meant.

10

1837.  Lockhart, Scott, IV. i. 18. The withholding of the avowal.

11

a. 1861.  Clough, Poems, Uranus, 3. The … blank profound, Which … holds All knowledge, ever by withholding holds.

12

1884.  Law Times Rep. (N.S.), LI. 242/2. If a party … obtains the sanction of the court by withholding information which is material … such withholding amounts to fraud.

13

  So withholding ppl. a., that withholds.

14

c. 1430.  Pilgr. Lyf Manhode, IV. xiii. (1869), 183. Withholdinge, and ful of cley, and … glewy is þilke.

15

1898.  W. Sharp, in Fortn. Rev., Aug., 305. The eternal duel between the desiring flesh and the withholding spirit is interpreted anew.

16